Shower Niches vs. Shower Shelves: Which Is Right for Your Bathroom?
When designing a new shower, storage may seem like a small detail—but it plays a major role in how your bathroom looks, feels, and functions every day. One of the most common questions we hear at CT Tile & Remodeling is:
“Should I choose a shower niche or a shower shelf?”
The answer depends on your shower layout, design style, and how you use the space. In this article, we’ll compare tile shower niches and metal shower shelves side by side to help you decide which option is right for your bathroom remodel.
This is Part 3 of our 3-part shower storage series, created to help homeowners make confident, informed decisions:
Part 1: Tile Shower Niches: Design Ideas & Placement Tips
Part2: Shower Shelves Explained: Built-In Storage Options for Modern Bathrooms
Quick Overview: What’s the Difference?
Shower niches are recessed storage compartments built into the shower wall and tiled to match or accent the surrounding design.
Shower shelves are surface-mounted metal shelves installed directly on the shower wall. At CT Tile & Remodeling, we use Schluter® metal shelves—both rectangular and corner styles—for durable, modern storage.
Both options work beautifully when designed and installed correctly—but they serve different needs.
Shower Niches: Pros & Considerations
Why Homeowners Choose Shower Niches
✔ Built into the wall for a seamless look
✔ Can blend in or stand out with accent tile
✔ Keeps items tucked away and visually clean
✔ Custom sizing and placement options
Shower niches are a great choice when you want storage that feels fully integrated into the tile design.
Things to Consider
Requires cutting into wall framing
Placement may be limited by plumbing or studs
Installation and waterproofing must be done correctly
Less flexible once built
Niches work best when planned early in the remodel and installed by experienced professionals using proper waterproofing systems.
Shower Shelves: Pros & Considerations
Why Homeowners Choose Shower Shelves
✔ No wall cavity required
✔ Flexible placement
✔ Modern, minimalist aesthetic
✔ Easy access to everyday items
✔ Excellent option when framing limits niches
At CT Tile & Remodeling, we install Schluter® metal shelves, including:
Rectangular shelves for generous storage
Corner shelves for compact or secondary storage
Coordinated Design Advantage
Schluter metal shelves can be matched to Schluter drains, including:
KERDI-DRAIN (center drains)
KERDI-LINE (linear drains)
Matching finishes between shelves and drains creates a cohesive, high-end look that many homeowners love.
Things to Consider
Slightly more visible than niches
Storage is open rather than recessed
For many homeowners, the flexibility and durability of metal shelves outweigh these considerations.
| Feature | Shower Niches | Metal Shower Shelves |
|---|---|---|
| Storage Style | Recessed into the wall | Surface-mounted |
| Design Look | Seamless or decorative tile detail | Clean, modern, minimalist |
| Placement Flexibility | Limited by wall framing and plumbing | Highly flexible placement |
| Installation Complexity | Higher (requires framing & waterproofing) | Moderate |
| Waterproofing Importance | Critical | Critical |
| Finish Coordination | Tile-based coordination | Can match Schluter drains & fixtures |
| Best For | Custom tile-forward designs | Modern, practical shower layouts |
Which Option Is Right for You?
Choose a shower niche if:
You want storage fully integrated into the wall
Tile design is a major focus
Wall framing allows proper placement
Space isn’t an issue
Choose metal shower shelves if:
You want flexibility in placement
Your shower layout limits niche options
You prefer a modern, minimalist style
You want coordinated finishes with Schluter drains
In some cases, homeowners even combine both—for example, a shelf can be placed inside a niche for additional storage.
Why Professional Design & Installation Matter
Both niches and shelves require proper waterproofing and expert installation. At CT Tile & Remodeling, we use Schluter waterproofing systems to ensure:
Long-term durability
Proper drainage
Protection behind the tile
A finished result built to last
We help homeowners choose the right solution—not just the most popular one.
Ready to Design a Shower That Works for You?
If you’re planning a bathroom remodel and deciding between shower niches and shower shelves, our team is here to help.
Schedule a free in-home estimate or visit our Glenside showroom to explore tile, shelf, and drain options in person.
If you liked this post, you’ll love these:
